Do we work harder when we're paid hourly?

Assembly-line workers are often paid hourly wages.­ See more power tool pictures.
© ­­iStockphoto/­chrisboy2004

­­

It's 4:15 on a Friday afternoon in July. From your cubicle, you can hear your office mates on their cell phones, making plans for barbecues, baseball games and camping trips. Suddenly, that report deadline doesn't seem so important. All you can think about is getting home, grabbing a cold drink and putting your feet up on the back porch.

You grab your coat and head for the door. You'd feel guilty about leaving early, but you put in 60 hours last ­week, or at least it felt like it. You can finish the report first thing Monday morning. Anyway, you think, it's not like they pay you by the hour.

Salaried employees only make up 40 percent of the United States workforce [source: Hunt]. The rest are paid by the hour. Hourly work is found in all industries: manufacturing, medical, IT, retail, hospitality and more. According to U.S. labor law, hourly jobs can't involve any management or leadership decisions and tend to be fairly routine in nature. Working on an assembly line or making burgers at a fast-food restaurant are examples of hourly jobs, but so are computer programming and some types of nursing [source: Hunt].

One major difference between hourly and salaried employees is that hourly work is subject to overtime pay. If an assembly line worker at a computer manufacturer in California works more than 40 hours during a single week, he'll get paid 1.5 times the normal hourly rate for every hour he works beyond 40 [source: Haines]. If his salaried manager works 62 hours during that same week, her paycheck won't go up at all. Salaried workers are exempt from overtime pay according to U.S. labor and tax law.

­

So the question is, do hourly employees work h­arder than their salaried colleagues because they feel more directly compensated for each hour of work? Or do salaried employees work harder because they generally receive bigger paychecks and feel a greater sense of responsibility to the company? Do more hourly workers goof around and pad their timesheets, or are salaried workers equally guilty of taking fake sick days and running personal errands on company time?

To answer these questions, we're going to start by looking into existing research on employee motivation and how factors like job satisfaction and a sense of ownership at the workplace affect job performance. We'll see how effective employee management can have a much bigger effect on employee productivity than whether a worker is paid by the hour or by the month.

­­­

Employee Motivation 101

The proper motivation can help keep employees from becoming discouraged.
The proper motivation can help keep employees from becoming discouraged.
© ­­­iStockphoto/JenD

There isn't much mystery behind our motivation to work. We seek employment because we need money. But interestingly, once we have a job, money is not necessarily the strongest motivator for working hard. According to research based on organizational theory and management theory, there are many other factors beyond money that influence our decision to finish that report or cut out 45 minutes early.

Job satisfaction plays a crucial role in worker productivity. According to recent survey results from the Families and Work Institute, 54 percent of all U.S. workers are less than fully satisfied with their jobs, and 39 percent are not fully engaged with their work [source: Bond]. A worker who isn't fully engaged is far less likely to put in the extra effort to be as productive as possible.

So why are so many workers dissatisfied with their jobs? It's because they haven't been properly motivated. According to research from the Harvard Business School, most employees are very enthusiastic when they first start a job, but quickly lose motivation after the first six months [source: Sirota]. It's not the employees who are to blame, says Harvard. It's their managers.

According to the researchers, workers have three goals when they look for a satisfying job: equity, achievement and camaraderie [source: Sirota]. First of all, everybody wants to be fairly and equally compensated for their work. That means receiving a fair market price for their labor as well as any benefits and perks that come with the job title.

Secondly, an employee needs to feel a sense of ownership in the success or failure of the business [source: O'Connor]. The worker needs to know that he or she is making a valuable contribution.

A manager can instill this sense of ownership in several ways. He or she can simply make a point of recognizing the employee's achievements, both publicly and privately [source: Boyer]. He or she can improve the employee's sense of camaraderie, team spirit and company pride by directly linking production numbers to profits and rewarding employees for reaching collective goals. The reward doesn't even have to be monetary. It could be an extra day off or a company party.

Labor experts point to Costco as an excellent example of a well-managed and motivated workplace. Costco employees are paid an average hourly wage­ of $15.97, which is 40 percent higher than the average hourly wage at Sam's Club, Costco's closest direct competitor [source: Holmes]. Cost­co hourly workers also receive competitive health insurance coverage, 401(k) accounts and profit-sharing plans. With these perks, Costco is able to attract and retain loyal, top-quality employees who feel ownership of the company's success.

The high job satisfaction of Costco employees translates directly into greater productivity. In 2004, Costco earned $13,647 in operating profit for each employee. Sam's Club earned only $11,039 per employee [source: Holmes].

So back to the question: Do we work harder when we're paid hourly? The answer depends on the workplace environment, the management philosophy, your coworkers and most of all, yourself. A properly motivated worker will work just as hard in a salaried job as an hourly one.

That said, researchers have identified some basic differences in what motivates hourly workers versus salaried workers. We'll take a closer look at these in the next section.

Why We Work Hard: Hourly vs. Salaried

­A­lthough there are all kinds of hourly and salaried jobs, researchers have come to some general conclusions about what motivates employees to work at their best.

Many hourly jobs, for example, are considered entry-level. Even though they're paid relatively little, entry-level employees work hard to separate themselves from the pack and win a promotion to a considerably higher-paying position [source: Carlton]. Each step up the ladder brings a significant raise, enough incentive to keep working hard.

Another motivation for many hourly workers is that success on the job is clearly defined [source: Ault]. Most hourly work is task-oriented. You make TVs all day long. You code software. You change IVs. There is a beginning and an end to each task that brings a sense of accomplishment. This limited scope of responsibility allows the hourly worker to separate work and home life easily. Once the job is done, you can go home and relax.

In a tough economy, the strongest motivation for many hourly workers is simply to keep their job. Hourly workers are some of the first to go in downsizing efforts. High unemployment means stiff competition for the jobs that remain. After a round of layoffs, the remaining workers sometimes find themselves doing the jobs of two or three other people in addition to their own. In this type of highly competitive, high-pressure environment, only the hardest workers will keep their positions [source: Beuttler].

­

­

Salaried workers, many of whom are managers of one kind or another, typically have greater responsibility, accountability and overall influence than hourly workers. The downside of this higher level of influence is that success is more difficult to define [source: Ault]. This helps explain why salaried workers, in general, work more hours per week than hourly workers [source: Kuhn]. Whereas the hourly worker can stop when his or her task is complete, the salaried worker has a harder time knowing when he or she's "done" since the indicators are far less objective.

Some salaried workers are heavily influenced and motivated by the work culture at the office. In technology start-ups, for example, there's a culture of working extraordinarily long hours. The idea is that by working extremely hard for no immediate reward, all money and energy is being invested in developing a breakout new product. Later, when your company is bought by a larger company or you decide to go public, the people who got in at the ground floor will be richly rewarded for their hard work [source: Carlson].

Not all workaholics are made to suffer and sacrifice, however. At workplaces like Google and Microsoft, salaried employees are givens loads of incentives to never leave the office. You can get delicious free meals at the office. You can get your clothes dry-cleaned, your shoes shined and your car washed at the office. You can even get haircuts and massages.

A final motivation for all workers, both hourly and salaried, is a genuine love for their work. Some people just can't get enough of their jobs. They think about their jobs all the time, constantly looking for ways to improve their performance, make more money and contribute to the success of the company. This makes for not only the ideal job, but the ideal employee.

For more great articles on work and business, follow the links on the next page.

Related HowStuffWorks Articles

More Great Links

Sources

  • Ault, John T. Southern Utah University Department of Psychology. "Professional vs. Employee."http://www.suu.edu/hss/Psychology/Practicum/prof.employ.html
  • Beuttler, Bill. Boston Magazine. "We Work Too Hard." Nov. 2001.http://www.bostonmagazine.com/articles/we_work_too_hard/
  • Bond, Terry and Galinsky, Ellen. Families and Work Institute. "How Can Employers Increase the Productivity and Retention of Entry-Level, Hourly Employees?" Nov. 2006.http://familiesandwork.org/site/research/reports/brief2.pdf
  • Boyer, Shawn. Business Chronicle. "Helping the Bottom Line by Retaining Hourly Workers." Jan. 2009.http://www.mybusinesschronicle.com/Retaining-Hourly-Workers
  • Carlton, Dennis W. and Perloff, Jeffrey M. Pearson Higher Education. "Motivating Workers."http://wps.aw.com/aw_carltonper_modernio_4/21/5566/1424934.cw/content/index.html
  • Carlson, Nicholas. Gawker. "Jason Calacanis doesn't really hate your family, but he does think you should look for work at the post office." March 25, 2008http://valleywag.gawker.com/371898/jason-calacanis-doesnt-really-hate-your-family-but-he-does-think-you-should-look-for-work-at-the-post-office
  • Haines, Walter L. California Labor Law. "California Overtime."http://www.californialaborlaw.info/overtime.htm
  • Holmes, Stanley and Zellner, Wendy. BusinessWeek. "The Costco Way." April 12, 2004.http://www.businessweek.com/magazine/content/04_15/b3878084_mz021.htm
  • Hunt, Steven T. Workforce Institute. "Increasing Hourly Workforce Productivity: Different types of work, different types of workers." May 2008.http://www.workforceinstitute.org/wp-content/uploads/2008/05/hunt-types-of-hourly-workers-03.pdf
  • Hunt, Steven T. Workforce Institute. "Treating Hourly Workers Like Professional Employees." Sept. 23, 2008.http://www.workforceinstitute.org/treating-hourly-workers-like-professional-employees.htm
  • Kuhn, P. and Lozano, F. Journal of Labor Economics. "The expanding workweek? Understanding trends in long work hours among U.S. men, 1979-2006." 2008http://wfnetwork.bc.edu/statistics_template.php?id=13833
  • O'Connor, Kathleen Ryan. Fortune Small Business. "Getting the Most Out of Your Hourly Workforce." Feb. 27, 2008.http://money.cnn.com/2008/02/25/smbusiness/motivating_employees.fsb/index.htm
  • Sirota, David; Mischkind, Louis; Meltzer, Michael Irwin. Harvard Business School. "Why Your Employees Are Losing Motivation." April 10, 2006.http://hbswk.hbs.edu/archive/5289.html