Criticism of Tax Rebate Plans
Learning to Repeat Past Mistakes
Political commentator Glenn Beck toys with the idea of issuing pre-paid debit cards rather than tax rebate checks. He points out that though this process proved disastrous when victims of Hurricane Katrina chose to use them on frivolous items, that same frivolous mind-set might help pump cash into the economy now. Another benefit: By putting an expiration date on the cards, people will have to spend them more quickly than they would a check or miss their opportunity.
So can tax rebates help to prevent a recession? Not necessarily. Many economists and political commentators think they merely delay an inevitable recession or even hurt countries in the long run. Here's a rundown of some objections:
- The rebate boost might act as a temporary delay for a downturn, like a pain reliever that wears off after a few hours. If individuals do spend their check quickly, a sudden increase in demand will shoot up and fade out, putting the economy back where it started and adding to the national debt (and the burden on future taxpayers).
- Even if consumers quickly blow their newfound money, the actual items people purchase might be foreign products, which wouldn't help the U.S. economy as much.
- It might be too difficult to time the rebates appropriately. The 2008 package may come too late to prevent a recession.
- Times are more troubled than they were in 2001 when a similar tax rebate measure passed. Economist Michael Niemira told the Wall Street Journal that debt has gotten so bad people will want to use their rebate check to pay off debt rather than consume more things [source: Waters].
- Tax rebates encourage spending rather than saving or investments, according to Brian Riedl of The Heritage Foundation. Riedl argues that cutting taxes to create jobs, incentives to work and investments could help the economy more significantly.
Overall, many agree that tax rebates provide at least temporary help and work best in conjunction with other fiscal and monetary policies that can help to prevent or relieve a recession. To learn more about personal finance and taxes, visit the links on the next page.
Related HowStuffWorks Articles
- How Recessions Work
- How Income Taxes Work
- How much money is "all the money in the world"?
- If all the money in the U.S. only totals $6 trillion, how can the New York Stock Exchange have stocks valued at $15 trillion?
- How Banks Work
More Great Links
- Tax Rebate Calculator
- Internal Revenue Service
- Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System
- Bureau of Economic Analysis
- Recession 411: What it is and How it Should Affect Your Investment Decisions
- Beck, Glenn. "Glenn Beck: Debit cards for everyone!" CNN.com. Feb. 12, 2008. (Feb. 15, 2008)
- Coy, Peter and Dawn Kopecki. "Looking For a Quick Fix." BusinessWeek. Feb. 4, 2008.
- The Economist. "Stampede to stimulus." Jan. 17, 2008. (Feb. 15, 2008)
- Hill, Patrice. "Stimulus package seen as cushion." Feb. 14, 2008. The Washington Times. (Feb. 15, 2008)
- Johnson, David, Jonathan Parker and Nicholas S. Souleles. "Household Expenditure and the Income Tax Rebates of 2001." September 2004. NBER Working Paper No. W10784. (Feb. 15, 2008) http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=593468
- Mankiw, Greg. "Proposed Fiscal Stimulus: My View." Jan. 24, 2008. Greg Mankiw's Blog. (Feb. 15, 2008) http://gregmankiw.blogspot.com/2008/01/proposed-fiscal-stimulus
- Neikirk, William. "Economic stimulus package puts President Bush, House leaders on same page." Jan. 25, 2008. Chicago Tribune. (Feb. 15, 2008) http://www.chicagotribune.com/business/chifri_stimulus
- Riedl, Brian M. "Why Tax Rate Reductions Are More Stimulative Than Rebates: Lessons from 2001 and 2003." The Heritage Foundation. Jan. 18, 2008. (Feb. 15, 2008)
- Sahadi, Jeanne. "Rebates: What you need to know." CNNMoney.com. Feb. 11, 2008. (Feb. 18, 2008)
- Samwick, Andrew A. "A Better Way to Deal With Downturns." The Washington Post. Jan. 27, 2008. (Feb. 15, 2008) http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/01/25/
- Waters, Jennifer. "Tax Rebates May Be Used To Cut Debt This Time." The Wall Street Journal. Jan. 22, 2008. (Feb. 15, 2008) http://online.wsj.com/public/article/SB120096365478305113.html