A successful relationship between union laborers and employers relies on a delicate balance of power. Some employers view the right to hire scab labor as a way to maintain that balance. They say that scabs are necessary bargaining chips at the negotiation table to combat unfair union demands.
This argument is hard to swallow for many union workers, but there's a certain logic to it, particularly in the case of smaller businesses [source: Lemay]. Imagine a factory in rural Michigan. Economic times are tough and the factory is barely making a profit. The union, upset that wages haven't increased in years, calls for a strike. Now the company is in an even tougher economic situation. With production at a standstill, it's losing hundreds of thousands of dollars a day, and the only way to get employees back to work is by meeting their demands.
By temporarily replacing union workers, the small company can generate some revenue while negotiations with the union continue. Some of the factory's economic pressure has been lifted, allowing both sides to approach the negotiating table on equal terms.
It can also be argued that the existence of scab labor may actually be a protection for union workers. Let's say that it was suddenly illegal to hire replacement workers -- legislation that's been proposed in U.S. and Canada for years. If you were running that factory in Michigan, you would do everything in your power to limit your exposure to labor unions [source: Lemay]. The more union workers you hire, the greater your risk if they go on strike. And without the option to hire replacement workers, you'll have to bow to the union's demands, even if you feel they're excessive.
Another argument for replacement workers is what's called the "market test theory" which is based on the principles of supply and demand [source: Ferrara]. Here's how it works: U.S. law permits a company to hire permanent replacement workers only in the case of an economic strike or a strike over wages -- not one based on workers seeking greater benefits or alleging unfair treatment. If a union calls a strike asking for a fair wage increase, then the employer will have a hard time finding replacement workers who will work for a below-market salary. However, if the union asks for an excessive or above-market wage increase, then the employer will easily find replacement workers willing to accept the lower but reasonable market price.
The market test theory argues that without the ability to hire permanent replacement labor, unions will exercise a monopoly that raises wages so far beyond fair market value that employers will no longer be able to do business [source: Ferrara].
As we've seen, quite a bit of controversy and risk of physical danger surrounds labor scabs. For lots more information on scabs, strikes and unions, follow the links below.
Related HowStuffWorks Articles
More Great Links
- Lexicon of Labor. "Scab." New Press. 1998http://www.labordallas.org/hist/hist1860.htm
- Online Etymology Dictionary. "Scab"http://www.etymonline.com/index.php?term=scab
- Farlex. The Free Dictionary. Legal Dictionary. "Unfair Labor Practice"http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/Unfair+Labor+Practice
- The United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit. "UNITED STEEL, PAPER AND FORESTRY, RUBBER, MANUFACTURING, ENERGY, ALLIED INDUSTRIAL AND SERVICE WORKERS INTERNATIONAL UNION, AFL-CIO v. NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS BOARD." September 15, 2008.
- Canadian Labour Congress. "Anti-Scab Legislation: the Case for Balance and Fairness." December 5, 2006.http://action.clc-ctc.ca/node/37
- PBS American Experience. "Andrew Carnegie: the Homestead Strike"http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/amex/carnegie/peopleevents/pande04.html
- Armstrong, Mick. Socialist Alternative. "Aust Radical History: The Great Strikes." April-May, 2007http://www.sa.org.au/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=68&Itemid=106
- Encyclopædia Britannica Online. "Herrin." October 17, 2008http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/263745/Herrin
- Diaz, Richard. The Love of Sports. "Scab Ball." May 18, 2008http://www.theloveofsports.com/index.php/site/comments/scab_ball/
- The Baseball Almanac. "Replacement Players in the Major Leagues"http://www.theloveofsports.com/index.php/site/comments/scab_ball/
- Kilborn, Peter T. The New York Times. "Replacement Workers: Management's Big Gun." March 13, 1990.http://query.nytimes.com/gst/fullpage.html?res=9C0CE4DF163BF930A25750C0A966958260
- Schlach, Kathleen. National Public Radio. "1981 Strike Leaves Legacy for American Workers." August 3, 2006http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=5604656
- Krueger, Alan B.; Mas, Alexandre. National Bureau of Economic Research. "Strikes, Scabs And Tread Separations: Labor Strife And The Production Of Defective Bridgestone/Firestone Tires." February, 2003.
- The New York Times. "Paris Plumbers on Strike." September 18, 1910.http://query.nytimes.com/mem/archive-free/pdf?_r=2&res=9B03E0DF1F39E333A2575BC1A96F9C946196D6CF&oref=slogin&oref=slogin
- BBC. "Wales History: The Miners' Strike"http://www.bbc.co.uk/wales/history/sites/themes/society/industry_coal06.shtml
- Mail Online. "'Scab' driver burned in his lorry as European protests against high fuel prices turn violent." June 13, 2008http://www.mailonsunday.co.uk/news/worldnews/article-1025783/Scab-driver-burned-lorry-European-protests-high-fuel-prices-turn-violent.html
- Lemay, Guy; Kozhaya, Norma. National Post. "Workers Pay for Anti-Scab Laws." January 8, 2005http://www.iedm.org/main/show_editorials_fr.php?editorials_id=87
- Noceda, Kristopher. Oakland Tribune. "Forget sticks and stones: Teachers aim at 'scabs.'" April 12, 2007http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_qn4176/is_/ai_n18997680